As many of you know, for the last three years, I have been working on my master’s degree in theology.
I’m now enrolled in the last class in this degree program. I expect to be completely finished before Christmas.
The next to last assignment in this class is for me to lead a Bible study. Pastor Jon has been kind enough to allow me to do that during this time in our worship service.
But, I need your help. You see, listening to a sermon can be a very passive exercise.
I know that many of you engage completely with the sermon. Some take notes. For example, Polly has the main points from every sermon she has heard at Joy for the last several years.
On the other hand, during a sermon, you can choose to sit quietly in your seat and not engage at all.
This morning, because this is a Bible study not a sermon, I need you to engage.
I’ll ask questions. I need you to reply. If you have questions, please ask.
If you want to add to the discussion, please put your hand up and we’ll discuss what you are thinking.
Context
This morning’s Bible study is going to focus on the book of James. I’ll start by providing some context.
While it’s not certain, James, the brother of Jesus and the leader of the Jerusalem church is most likely the author of the book bearing his name. This is consistent with early church tradition.
Scholars believe that the book of James was not written before about AD 40 because James seems to be addressing apparently mature Christian congregations.
James describes communities as having established assemblies (James 2:2), he recognizes teachers in the churches (James 3:1), and he also recognizes church elders (James 5:14).
The church was born on the Day of Pentecost which happened between AD 30–AD 33.
Many Scholars believe it would have taken a few years for these churches to develop the organizational structures, and candidly, the problems James describes.
AD 40 is not a firm date. It is possible that James could have been written earlier, but scholars generally agree that this is a reasonable date for the earliest James might have been written.
The likely date of the death of James, the presumed author, is AD 62. Therefore, that is the most accepted date for the latest James might have been completed.
Therefore, scholars generally agree that the likely date for the writing of this book was between AD 40 and AD 62.
The Jerusalem Council occurred in approximately AD 49.
The biggest issue discussed at the Jerusalem Council was whether or not Gentiles had to convert to Judaism, and be circumcised, before they could become Christians.
The council concluded that Gentiles did not need to convert to Judaism before becoming Christians.
James played a leadership role in the Jerusalem Council, yet this issue was never discussed in the book of James.
Many biblical scholars believe that the reason this issue was not discussed in the book of James is that the council had not occurred at the time James penned his Epistle.
That leaves a probable date for the writing of James somewhere between AD 40 and AD 49. If accurate, this would make James among the earliest books of the New Testament to be written.
James writes in the context of the Roman world, where wealth and status created sharp social divisions. Poverty, exploitation, and trials pressured believers.
James addresses favoritism, rivalry, harmful speech, and neglect of those in need. This reveals communities struggling to express their professed faith through consistent obedience and love.
James 1:1 states that the book is addressed to “the twelve tribes which are scattered abroad.” These people are commonly understood to be Jewish believers living outside of Palestine.
Therefore, James was probably written to multiple congregations spread across the Roman Empire rather than one local congregation.
The way James is written suggests that the audience was familiar with Old Testament Scripture and metaphors, synagogue terminology, and Jewish traditions.
This supports Jews living in the Diaspora as likely recipients of the letter.
However, the congregations would also likely have included some Gentile God-fearers who worshipped in the synagogues but had not converted to Judaism.
Bible Study
This morning, we’re going to focus on James 2:14–26. By the way, I’m going to bounce around to a lot of Scriptures, but if you want to keep your finger in this passage, we will come back to it frequently.
In this passage, James discusses the role that works play in salvation.
James 2:14
14 What doth it profit, my brethren, though a man say he hath faith, and have not works? can faith save him?
James addresses this verse to “my brethren.” So, he is writing to believers.
James asks, what good does it do if a professed believer says he has faith, but his life does not manifest good works? Can faith save him?
Now, we should be clear. The earlier part of verse 14 specifies the type of faith James is discussing. Specifically, he is talking about faith that is not manifest in works.
Can this kind of faith save a person? This is a rhetorical question, meaning it is asked to make a point rather than to obtain information.
One of the reasons the question is rhetorical is that the question itself tells us the expected answer.
It can do this because the Greek carries meaning that English can’t easily convey.
In this question, the Greek word μή (mē) appears. The Greek spelling is μή (mu, eta). The word mē conveys that the rhetorical question expects a negative answer.
By the way, if James had wanted the rhetorical question to convey that it was expecting a positive answer, he would have used the word οὐ (ou). The Greek spelling is οὐ (omicron, upsilon).
For example, in 1 Corinthians 9:1, Paul writes:
1 Corinthians 9:1
1 Am I not an apostle? am I not free? have I not seen Jesus Christ our Lord? are not ye my work in the Lord?
The word “not” appears four times in the verse. These questions all use ou or ou related forms signaling that Paul expects an affirmative answer. None of them use mē.
So, Paul is saying:
- I am an apostle.
- I am
- I have seen Jesus Christ.
- And, you are my work in the Lord.
Both of these two words, ou which expects a positive answer, and mē which expects a negative answer are typically translated as “not.”
Now, some of you, who are paying close attention, are about ready to call me out.
Why would you be calling me out?
The word “not” doesn’t show up in the final question in James 2:14. So, if “not” isn’t in the question how can this question convey whether it expects a positive or a negative answer?
It is true that this is a rhetorical question that expects a negative answer, but in the King James Version the question doesn’t contain the word “not.”
Does anyone know how this could be? How can this rhetorical question signal that it expects a negative answer when the word “not” isn’t in the question?
I pulled out my Greek New Testament and turned to James 2:14. In the Greek, the word mē is absolutely there. It just didn’t get translated as “not” in the King James Version.
By the way, if you go to the Blue Letter Bible that Pastor Jon spoke to us about last Sunday and you look at the “Forward” translation from Greek to the King James Version, it shows that mē is in the Greek, but it’s not translated in the KJV.
It might make the expected answer more explicit in English if the KJV had translated that question, “Faith without works cannot save him, can it?”
So, James clearly wrote that question to convey that “faith without works is not a saving faith!” In other words, people who are saved will perform good works.
Does this throw up a red flag for anyone?
It sure does for me, because I know Paul wrote in:
Ephesians 2:8–9
8 For by grace are ye saved through faith; and that not of yourselves: it is the gift of God:
9 Not of works, lest any man should boast.
We seem to have a contradiction here:
- James seems to be saying, you can’t be saved without works,
- Paul seems to be saying, we are saved by faith alone, no works you could do will help with salvation.
In all probability, this wasn’t an accident.
James and Paul knew each other. In Galatians 1:18–19, Paul is speaking about the time right after his Damascus Road experience. He says:
Galatians 1:18–19
18 Then after three years I went up to Jerusalem to see Peter, and abode with him fifteen days.
19 But other of the apostles saw I none, save James the Lord's brother.
In Galatians 2:9, Paul says that fourteen years later he returned to Jerusalem.
Galatians 2:9
9 And when James the brother of Jesus, Cephas aka Peter, and John, who seemed to be pillars, perceived the grace that was given unto me, they gave to me and Barnabas the right hands of fellowship; that we should go unto the heathen, and they unto the circumcision.
They discussed their respective ministries and agreed that Paul would minister primarily to Gentiles and James, as the head of the Jerusalem church, would minister primarily to Jews.
In Galatians 2:2, Paul had written:
Galatians 2:2a
2a And I went up by revelation, and communicated unto them that gospel which I preach among the Gentiles…
So, we know that James and Paul knew each other. We also know that they discussed the gospel that Paul was preaching.
Therefore, it is very likely that James was well aware of Paul’s doctrine that we are saved by faith… not by works.
My suspicion is that James penned James 2:14 which could very easily be interpreted to mean that works are necessary for salvation very intentionally.
I think he wanted to make people’s head snap around. He wanted to grab people’s attention. He wanted people to think, how could James contradict Paul?
Let me be clear, this is my perception. There is nothing in Scripture that says this. This is just me reading between the lines.
So, we have this seeming conflict between Paul and James:
- Paul says we are saved by faith, not by works.
- James seems to say you can’t be saved without works.
Would anyone like to share how this seeming conflict can be resolved?
First, immediately after Paul says we are saved by faith, not by works in Ephesians 2:8–9, he acknowledges that believers are created for good works in the next verse:
Ephesians 2:10
10 For we are his workmanship, created in Christ Jesus unto good works, which God hath before ordained that we should walk in them.
Paul denies that our works earn salvation, but he continues saying that believers are created in Christ for good works.
As for James, the resolution to this dilemma is a bit nuanced:
- James is actually not saying that we are saved based on works.
- He’s saying that if we have true saving faith… it will manifest itself with works.
Works are the result of saving faith, not the cause of salvation.
James is guarding against what the youth group I grew up in used to call people trying to take out “fire insurance!”
Here is how someone seeking “fire insurance” might mistakenly reason—treating belief as a cost-free precaution rather than a life changing commitment to Jesus Christ.
The logic goes like this:
- If I believe… and it turns out that everything Jesus told us is true… when I die, I go to heaven (the biggest win ever!).
- If I believe… and it turns out everything Jesus told us is wrong… when I die, I’m just gone into nothingness.
- If I don’t believe… and it turns out that everything Jesus told us is true… when I die, I go to hell (the biggest loss ever!).
- If I don’t believe… and it turns out that everything Jesus told us is wrong… when I die, I’m just gone into nothingness.
Okay, let’s think about this:
- If I believe… there is potentially a lot of upside, but no downside.
- If I don’t believe… there is potentially a lot of downside, but no upside.
Okay, given those two options… I think I’ll choose the one with upside, but no downside… I’ll choose to believe… why wouldn’t I?
Someone might say, “I’ll profess belief so that I’m covered when I die,” while having no intention of trusting or obeying Christ.
Basically, they are saying they’ll take some “fire insurance.” In other words, they’re trying to insure against the possibility of hell.
James says no, no, no! It’s not enough to just say you believe. You must have faith that changes your life… such a faith, will always result in good works.
As biblical scholars Walter Elwell and Robert Yarbrough said, “Paul and James agree that authentic trust in Jesus Christ results in good works.”
Point 1 – You cannot earn salvation through good works, but if you truly have saving faith, the result will be that you do good works!
James goes on to support this assertion with four different examples:
Example 1 – Cold & Hungry Believers
Returning to the 2nd chapter of James.
James 2:15–18
15 If a brother or sister be naked, and destitute of daily food,
Let’s be clear here, we’re talking about a believer with physical needs.
I’m not saying that we shouldn’t help non-believers with physical needs. At Joy, we do that frequently.
But, in this example, James is talking about believers because he refers to a brother or a sister. Going back to verse 15.
15 If a brother or sister be naked, and destitute of daily food,
16 And one of you say unto them, Depart in peace, be ye warmed and filled; notwithstanding ye give them not those things which are needful to the body; what doth it profit?
James is asking, what good does it do to offer a blessing to someone who is cold and hungry, but not give them warm clothes or food?
What are your thoughts about the answer to James’ question? Why are kind words insufficient when someone lacks food or clothing?
Continuing in verse 17.
17 Even so faith, if it hath not works, is dead, being alone.
James is saying that offering blessings to people who are cold and hungry, but not meeting their physical needs is like faith that doesn’t manifest itself in works. Neither is meaningful.
The blessing alone doesn’t meet the needs of the cold and hungry. It does them no good whatsoever.
Faith that doesn’t manifest itself in works is not saving faith. Faith that doesn’t save is worse than useless.
Picking up in verse 18:
18 Yea, a man may say, Thou hast faith, and I have works: shew me thy faith without thy works, and I will shew thee my faith by my works.
We’ve seen that James describes someone who claims to have faith but has no works. What distinguishes merely claiming to have faith from genuine saving faith?
Works are the manifestation of true saving faith.
Point 1 – You cannot earn salvation through good works, but if you truly have saving faith, the result will be that you do good works!
Point 2 – Works are the manifestation of true saving faith.
Example 2 – Demons
Continuing in James 2:19.
James 2:19
19 Thou believest that there is one God; thou doest well: the devils also believe, and tremble.
In the first century believing that there was only one God typically marked one as either a Jew or a Christian. Pagans were typically polytheistic, worshipping multiple gods.
Of course, this belief is accurate. There is only one God. It’s completely correct! However, James points out that demons also believe this truth.
What point is James making here?
Believing a truth is not enough in and of itself. The belief must be accompanied by obedient action.
The devils believe, but their belief is not accompanied by obedient action. In fact, the exact opposite is true. They continue to rebel against God.
Point 1 – You cannot earn salvation through good works, but if you truly have saving faith, the result will be that you do good works!
Point 2 – Works are the manifestation of true saving faith.
Point 3 – Accurate belief, without obedient action, is insufficient.
Example 3 – Abraham
Let’s go back to the 2nd chapter of James, verse 20.
James 2:20–24
20 But wilt thou know, O vain man, that faith without works is dead?
In this case, “vain” doesn’t mean conceited, which is the meaning I usually assign to this word. Instead, it means empty or foolish.
James is saying, “Do you want to be shown, you foolish person, that faith without works is useless?”
James then uses Abraham as an example of faith that was manifest in works.
21 Was not Abraham our father justified by works, when he had offered Isaac his son upon the altar?
Some of you are already thinking, this is another rhetorical question containing the word “not.” Does the Greek tell us the answer James is expecting? The answer is that it most assuredly does.
What word would you be looking for in the Greek?
If you go to the Blue Letter Bible, and study James 2:21, you will learn that the word “not” in the question “Was not Abraham our father justified by works?” is the translation of the Greek word ou not the Greek word mē.
So, James is saying, “Abraham was justified by works.”
Abraham’s obedience demonstrated his faith. His willingness to surrender Isaac showed that his trust in God went way beyond mere words or intellectual agreement.
Abraham’s trust in God was the product of a very deep faith.
Continuing in verse 22:
22 Seest thou how faith wrought with his works, and by works was faith made perfect?
When James says, “faith wrought with his works,” he’s saying that
Abraham’s faith and actions worked together.
James concludes the sentence with, “by works was faith made perfect.”
In this case, “perfect” does not mean sinless, it means that Abraham’s faith accomplished its intended purpose.
Abraham’s faith and actions worked together. His trust moved him to obey, and through that costly obedience his faith accomplished its intended purpose. His faith was completed.
23 And the scripture was fulfilled which saith, Abraham believed God, and it was imputed unto him for righteousness: and he was called the Friend of God.
24 Ye see then how that by works a man is justified, and not by faith only.
Abraham’s obedience did not purchase God’s acceptance. Rather, his obedience was the evidence of his faith. When we are saved by faith, the evidence is seen in our works.
You are all, no doubt, familiar with the story of God telling Abraham to offer Isaac as a burnt offering. It began with God making Abraham an especially important promise. In:
Genesis 15:5–6
5 And he God brought him Abraham forth abroad, and said, Look now toward heaven, and tell the stars, if thou be able to number them: and he said unto him, So shall thy seed be.
God’s promise to Abraham was that he would have innumerable descendants.
6 And he Abraham believed in the Lord; and he the Lord counted it to him for righteousness.
Notice that Abraham was counted righteous when he believed God, before the offering of Isaac in Genesis 22. His later obedience revealed his faith that already existed.
This is the verse that James quoted in the first part of James 2:23:
James 2:23a
23a And the scripture was fulfilled which saith, Abraham believed God…
God made a wonderful promise to Abraham, that he would have countless descendants, but he refined that promise:
Genesis 21:12
12 And God said unto Abraham, Let it not be grievous in thy sight because of the lad, and because of thy bondwoman; in all that Sarah hath said unto thee, hearken unto her voice; for in Isaac shall thy seed be called.
In other words, Abraham’s innumerable descendants will come through Isaac. That must have made God’s command to Abraham just a few short verses later confusing, at best.
Genesis 22:2
2 And he God said, Take now thy son, thine only son Isaac, whom thou lovest, and get thee into the land of Moriah; and offer him there for a burnt offering upon one of the mountains which I will tell thee of.
From Abraham’s perspective, this must have seemed contrary to God’s promise.
God had promised to make Abraham’s descendants a great nation and that these descendants would come through Isaac.
Now, God tells Abraham to sacrifice Isaac. This was certainly something contrary to Abraham’s understanding of what was going to happen.
Faced with this dilemma, Abraham exemplified a principle later expressed in Proverbs.
Proverbs 3:5
5 Trust in the Lord with all thine heart; and lean not unto thine own understanding.
Would you say that Abraham leaned unto his own understanding?
If Abraham had leaned unto his own understanding, do you think he would have proceeded with sacrificing Isaac?
I agree, I don’t think Abraham leaned unto his own understanding. I expect that if Abraham had leaned unto his own understanding, he would never have been willing to sacrifice Isaac.
From a merely human perspective, sacrificing Isaac appeared to threaten the promise. But Abraham did not limit God’s ability to what he himself could understand.
Hebrews explains that Abraham reasoned God could even raise Isaac from the dead. This helps to explain Abraham’s confidence.
Hebrews 11:17–19
17 By faith Abraham, when he was tried, offered up Isaac: and he that had received the promises offered up his only begotten son,
18 Of whom it was said, That in Isaac shall thy seed be called:
19 Accounting that God was able to raise him up, even from the dead; from whence also he received him in a figure.
Obviously, Abraham didn’t know exactly how God would fulfill his promise. He thought that perhaps, he would raise Isaac from the dead.
But, what Abraham was certain of is that God would fulfill his promise… because God always fulfills his promises.
Of course, as it turned out, God stopped Abraham before he sacrificed Isaac… but after Abraham had demonstrated his willingness to obey God in spite of the high cost of obedience.
Genuine faith enables obedience even when God’s plan is not clear.
When God’s plan is not clear to us, it doesn’t mean that God doesn’t have a plan, it just means that we don’t yet understand it.
I’m reminded of a visiting pastor who asked an old farmer, decked out in bib overalls, if he would say grace before the morning breakfast at church.
The farmer began, “Lord, I hate buttermilk.”
The visiting pastor opened one eye to glance at the farmer and wondered where this was going.
The farmer loudly proclaimed, “Lord, I hate lard.” Now the pastor was growing quite concerned.
Without missing a beat, the farmer continued, “And Lord, you know I don't much care for raw white flour.”
The pastor once again opened an eye to glance around the room and saw that he wasn't the only one feeling uncomfortable.
Then the farmer added, “But Lord, when you mix them all together and bake them, I do love warm, fresh biscuits.”
“So Lord, when things come up that we don't like… when life gets hard… when we don't understand your plan for us… help us to just relax and wait until you are done mixing.”
“It'll probably be even better than biscuits. Amen.”
Genuine faith will enable us to trust God’s plan, even when we don’t understand it.
We may not understand how everything fits together in this life. Abraham’s example calls us to trust God while we obey what he has made clear.
Point 1 – You cannot earn salvation through good works, but if you truly have saving faith, the result will be that you do good works!
Point 2 – Works are the manifestation of true saving faith.
Point 3 – Accurate belief, without obedient action, is insufficient.
Point 4 – Genuine faith enables obedience even when we do not understand God’s plan.
Example 4 – Rahab
Returning to the 2nd chapter of James in the 25th verse.
James 2:25
25 Likewise also was not Rahab the harlot justified by works, when she had received the messengers, and had sent them out another way?
Here’s another rhetorical question. Let’s see what the Greek tells us about the answer James is expecting.
What Greek word are you looking for?
Another trip to the Blue Letter Bible, tells us that the word “not” in the question “Likewise also was not Rahab the harlot justified by works?” is the translation of the Greek word ou not the Greek word mē.
So, James is saying, “Rahab the harlot was justified by her works.”
You’re probably familiar with the story of Rahab. Joshua sent two men to spy on the land of Jericho.
They went to Rahab’s house and stayed there. However, the king of Jericho learned about the spies and that they had gone to Rahab’s house.
The king sent men to Rahab’s house to capture the spies, but Rahab hid the spies.
She told the king’s men that the spies had come to her house, but they had already left. She told them that if they moved quickly, they could catch the spies.
Because of Rahab’s actions, the men Joshua sent to Jericho returned safely.
Rahab had confessed her faith in the God of Israel in the second half of Joshua 2:11 when she said to the Jewish spies:
Joshua 2:11b
11b …the Lord your God, he is God in heaven above, and in earth beneath.
Rahab believed that the God of Israel was in control.
Protecting the spies put Rahab’s life in great danger, but because of her faith she acted to save them.
How did God reward Rahab’s actions?
When the Israelites came to conquer Jericho all the inhabitants of Rahab’s house were spared (Joshua 6:22–25).
Point 1 – You cannot earn salvation through good works, but if you truly have saving faith, the result will be that you do good works!
Point 2 – Works are the manifestation of true saving faith.
Point 3 – Accurate belief, without obedient action, is insufficient.
Point 4 – Genuine faith enables obedience even when we do not understand God’s plan.
Point 5 – Genuine faith enables obedience even in the face of real danger.
In closing, there is an interesting contrast between Abraham and Rahab:
- Abraham was a man. Rahab was a woman.
- Abraham was a major figure in the Bible. Rahab was a minor player.
- Abraham was Israel’s patriarch. Rahab was a Gentile.
- Abraham was very respected. Rahab was a woman of ill repute.
In his commentary on the book of James, the biblical scholar J. A. Motyer says, if the relationship between faith and works applies to people as different as these two, it applies to everyone.
While it is true that there were many differences between Abraham and Rahab, they shared one very important thing.
What was the most important thing that Abraham and Rahab shared?
They both had a profound faith that was revealed in their actions.
James concludes this passage by restating his primary thesis:
James 2:26
26 For as the body without the spirit is dead, so faith without works is dead also.
I’ll close with one final question.
What is one specific action this week through which you can put your faith into practice?
I don’t need for you to answer this question publically. Keep it in your heart, ponder it, and when you come up with an answer, let your faith show through your good works.
Please bow your heads in prayer.
Heavenly Father,
Thank you for the gift of salvation through Jesus Christ. Help us to live out the faith we profess, so that our love for you becomes visible through obedience, generosity, and service.
Forgive us when we offer comforting words but fail to provide practical help. Open our eyes to those who lack food, clothing, or other necessities.
Give us the wisdom to respond thoughtfully and the compassion to act in your will.
Like Abraham, help us trust you when we cannot fully understand your purposes.
Like Rahab, give us courage to act faithfully when obedience involves risk.
Keep convenience, fear, and concern for our reputation from becoming barriers to doing your will.
Guard us from confusing knowledge about you with genuine trust in you.
May our works flow from living faith, bringing help to others and glory to your name.
We pray in Christ’s most holy name. Amen
Those who are participating in the Christmas pageant, please be ready for practice to start very soon.
Parents, please collect your children who are in the pageant and bring them back to the sanctuary as quickly as you can.
Those who are able, please stand as we worship our Lord!
Thank you for worshipping with us this morning. You are dismissed.
Scriptures
James 2:14
1 Corinthians 9:1
Ephesians 2:8–9
Galatians 1:18–19
Galatians 2:9
Galatians 2:2
Ephesians 2:10
Point 1
James 2:15–18
Point 2
James 2:19
Point 3
James 2:20–24
Genesis 15:5–6
James 2:23a
Genesis 21:12
Genesis 22:2
Proverbs 3:5
Hebrews 11:17–19
Point 4
James 2:25
Joshua 2:11b
Point 5
James 2:26
Key Points
Point 1 – You cannot earn salvation through good works, but if you truly have saving faith, the result will be that you do good works!
Point 2 – Works are the manifestation of true saving faith.
Point 3 – Accurate belief, without obedient action, is insufficient.
Point 4 – Genuine faith enables obedience even when we do not understand God’s plan.
Point 5 – Genuine faith enables obedience even in the face of real danger.